ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Development of Classification and Catalog of Software for Modeling Argumentation and Deliberative Reasoning

Elena Lisanyuk    
Dmitry Prokudin    

Resumen

As a result of the conducted research, we propose an approach to the development of a comprehensive classification of software applications, software and information systems designed for modeling and representation of argumentation, broad-based deliberative reasoning, support of decision-making processes and the formation of argumentation and critical thinking skills. The classification is based on the corpus of criteria developed as a result of this study, which determine the essential characteristics and functional features of such software, which must be taken into account when developing software for modeling argumentation, especially software with the function of evaluating arguments and finding solutions. The classification takes into account different types of justifications and counterarguments, the features of dialogues where arguments are given, and the structure of arguments of different types, including deliberative arguments. Based on the developed classification, a catalog is proposed in which descriptions of the corresponding software are made using the DCMES metadata scheme, which in the application plan is aimed at creating an electronic catalog in a machine-readable format. We have proposed a palliative solution for implementing the catalog in a machine-readable format. The proposed approach aims not only to support a rational and reasonable choice of software systems and applications for use in solving user tasks in the academic, research and educational communities, but also to serve as a tool for the prompt selection of appropriate software based on a search for metadata describing it.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Karma Tempa, Masengo Ilunga, Abhishek Agarwal and Tashi    
Gelephu, located in the Himalayan region, has undergone significant development activities due to its suitable topography and geographic location. This has led to rapid urbanization in recent years. Assessing land use land cover (LULC) dynamics and Norma... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
J. D. Tamayo-Quintero, J. B. Gómez-Mendoza and S. V. Guevara-Pérez    
Objective: This study aims to introduce and assess a novel AI-driven tool developed for the classification of orthodontic arch shapes into square, ovoid, and tapered categories. Methods: Between 2016 and 2019, we collected 450 digital dental models. Appl... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Yongzhen Zhang, Yanbo Hui, Ying Zhou, Juanjuan Liu, Ju Gao, Xiaoliang Wang, Baiwei Wang, Mengqi Xie and Haonan Hou    
Moldy corn produces aflatoxin and gibberellin, which can have adverse effects on human health if consumed. Mold is a significant factor that affects the safe storage of corn. If not detected and controlled in a timely manner, it will result in substantia... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Yu Sun and Zhiqiang Zhang    
Accurately classifying degraded images is a challenging task that relies on domain expertise to devise effective image processing techniques for various levels of degradation. Genetic Programming (GP) has been proven to be an excellent approach for solvi... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Károly Héberger    
Background: The development and application of machine learning (ML) methods have become so fast that almost nobody can follow their developments in every detail. It is no wonder that numerous errors and inconsistencies in their usage have also spread wi... ver más
Revista: Algorithms