ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Integrated contract in Law 14.133/2021: new law, same problems? A study of comparative law

Bruno Ribeiro Marques    
Odilon Cavallari de Oliveira    
Paulo Cavichioli Carmona    

Resumen

The purpose of this article is to analyze whether expansion allowed cases for design-build biddings might improve positive impacts on the efficiency of public procedures. Hence, both Brazilian and international experiences will be studied with attention to design-build and turnkey contracts. In integrated contracting procurements, basic and executive projects must be done by the same company that shall execute the project and its further execution. Consequently, public Administration must only provide a draft. Resolutely, the hypothesis is that these amplification allowances increase the risks of other contract failures. The methodology used was a dialectical-inductive method comparing both Brazilian and international cases of integrated contracts. Firstly, it is demonstrated when Design-Build procurements were first allowed in Brazil and how and why their uses have been amplified. Additionally, the international scenario shall be examined to determine if restrictions imposed by most countries have accompanied the use of integrated contracts for public Administration in Brazil. Subsequently, a comparative examination of several hiring public models will be examined to answer whether integrated contracts biddings might benefit public sectors. The conclusion is that significant expansion of possibilities of using the integrated contracting, forecasted in Law 14.133/2021, poses risks of reducing the efficiency of public administration unless several measures are to be adopted in the planning phase with particular attention to those related to the draft selecting requirements, just like most developed countries have already done.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Mariana Puspa Dewi,Ifelda Nengsih     Pág. 89 - 102
Previous research tends to discuss the management of waqf assets obtained from testament waqf, but this study focuses on the management of the instrument of testament waqf that is attached to life insurance by PT.AXA Financial Indonesia. This study ... ver más

 
Tony Kinder,Frédérique Six,Jari Stenvall,Antti Talonen,Ally Memon     Pág. 5 - 26
Linking with the debate around new public management (NPM) and new public governance (NPG), the article studies different conceptual approaches for explaining dynamically changing systems that locally deliver integrated health and social care. To make ou... ver más

 
Abdulrazaq Kayode Abdulkareem,Abdulrasaq Ajadi Ishola,Zulpha Jumoke Abdulkareem     Pág. 1 - 20
This paper explored the successes and challenges of Information and Communications Technology (ICT) adoption in the combat against bureaucratic corruption in the Nigerian public service. This study adopted a qualitative approach via in-depth interviews f... ver más

 
Ridwan Arifin,Intan Nurkumalawati     Pág. 127 - 144
Some challenges appear in this issue that the Indonesian border agencies indicate weaknesses in coordination, fragmented policy instruments, and disputes in implementing laws. There has little evidence in the previous study about the integration of borde... ver más

 
Benjamin Friedländer     Pág. 58 - 78
Due to the institutional differentiation of the public sector, which lead to a hardly comprehensible network of organisations from local administration, public economy and the third sector, the critical question of the importance of the integrated steeri... ver más