ARTÍCULO
TITULO

How Much Evidence Is There Really? Mapping the Evidence Base for ICT4D Interventions

Annette N. Brown    
Hannah J. Skelly    

Resumen

To identify impact evaluations on the effectiveness of ICTD interventions, we conducted a systematic search and screening that identiªed 253 studies. We present our results in an evidence map that shows the amount of evidencefor each of 11 intervention categories across nine development sectors. We ªnd large amounts of evidence for some intervention categories and little to no evidence in others. Roughly 80% of the ICTD impact evaluations use randomizedassignment, suggesting a relatively low risk of bias across the evidence base. At the same time, roughly 80% evaluate pilot implementations instead of programs, raising questions about how useful the evidence is for informing programs at scale. Less than 20% of studies report costs, limiting our ability to assess cost effectiveness. We make four recommendations to improve the evidence base.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Alessio Marrone, Maria Cristina Mangano, Alan Deidun, Manuel Berlino and Gianluca Sarà    
Habitat fragmentation (HF) is an ecological process, which is potentially also one of the main causes of diversity loss. Many studies have debated the best tools to adopt for assessing the effects of HF. The traditional application of biodiversity metric... ver más

 
Francesca Sasanelli, Khang Duy Ricky Le, Samuel Boon Ping Tay, Phong Tran and Johan W. Verjans    
The advent of many popular commercial forms of natural language processing tools has changed the way we can utilise digital technologies to tackle problems with big data. The objective of this review is to evaluate the current research and landscape of n... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Tomohiro Sonobe    
It has been proven that extended resolution (ER) has more powerful reasoning than general resolution for the pigeonhole principle in Cook?s paper. This fact indicates the possibility that a solver based on extended resolution can exceed Boolean satisfiab... ver más
Revista: Algorithms

 
Shijun Xu, Yi Hou, Xinpu Deng, Peibo Chen and Shilin Zhou    
The negation of probability distribution is a new perspective from which to obtain information. Dempster?Shafer (D?S) evidence theory, as an extension of possibility theory, is widely used in decision-making-level fusion. However, how to reasonably const... ver más
Revista: Information

 
Petros Lameras and Sylvester Arnab    
This exploratory review attempted to gather evidence from the literature by shedding light on the emerging phenomenon of conceptualising the impact of artificial intelligence in education. The review utilised the PRISMA framework to review the analysis a... ver más
Revista: Information